by Guest Author 33 comments

Appetite For Traffic? The Secret Is in the Source

156 Flares 156 Flares ×

blog commening traffic sourceWe all want traffic – that much is a no brainer, but where we get it from and the methods we employ to actually get it can make or break the growth of your blog.

Like a good pasta sauce, a slight tweaking of the ingredients can make a huge difference to the resulting flavor, so let’s examine some of those ingredients and see if we can help you to spice up the traffic coming to your blog.

How to Cook the Perfect Bloghetti

If you were to cook up a pasta sauce, would you just go and throw every ingredient in the cupboard into the frying pan and hope for the best or would you meticulously add a pinch of this and a spoonful of that, slowly testing each time until you had the balance of flavors just right?

(Note from Ana: are we talking about hurrying up with dinner while the kids are bawling and the husband/wife are nagging or a gourmet meal here?)

I won’t even wait for an answer; the question was a rhetorical one anyway and because it’s quite obvious what you would do.

You would order Pizza, who makes their own pasta sauce anyway? I mean really?!

So why then, when you are building backlinks and backchat to your blog, do you just open the Browser and throw everything at it?!

Ingredients have a history, a reason for being added in the first place and and if you start assessing every backlink in the same light you begin to see the bigger picture, which will help you get noticed – a lot sooner.

Let’s examine the best and worst ingredients out there.

Without doubt, the best ingredient will always be the blog comment.

A blog comment takes about the same time to complete as manually social bookmarking your latest post on a site like Digg or StumbleUpon for example, but the difference in taste is huge.

When you Blog Comment, you need to look at the bigger picture as to why you are commenting there in the first place.

  • Who is this blogger?
  • Who are their readers?
  • What are they trying to achieve?
  • What drives their readers?
  • How can I help them?

Big Fish

Big name bloggers are great to build relationships with because they open the doors to so much more.

Engaging on a bigger blog can get you exposure that social media, for example could never achieve and not only are you building backlinks to your site and a relationship with the blogger, you are boosting your online credibility (assuming the comments you leave are worth their salt).

Little Fish

Everyone else basically.

Limiting your engagement to the bigger blogs is a bad idea, and will ultimately limit the flavor of your blog.

Just like ingredients, the seemingly insignificant ones can add the most incredible tastes to your sauce – and until you experiment with them all, you can never know what works.

Smaller blogs are run by motivated bloggers who are still in their prime. They are also usually looking to engage just like you are – so take advantage of this!

Is it better than a Guest Post?

Most definitely!

If I comment regularly here at Traffic Generation Cafe for example and then submit a guest post, then it work wonders to boost blog traffic (Crosses fingers and waits for residual traffic from Ana :) )
This is only because I have already built some basic relationship with Ana and the readers (hi, I’m Alex in case we have not been formally introduced), so when I guest post, it simply cements this.

If I were to have submitted a guest post here without ever visiting or commenting before (assuming it was accepted and published), then I highly doubt my post or my name would be remembered all that well.

I don’t care how awesome the post. In fact, write an awesome post and give it to a blog where you have no relationship and chances are your post will be forever remembered as THEIRS!

There is nothing Del.icio.us about it

What about Social Bookmarking?

Surely you must do that right? I mean everyone does that.

There is nothing wrong with social bookmarking, in fact I have to go on record now and say that I recommend it, but to what end?

It realistically takes about the same amount of time to bookmark your page on a few sites as it does to leave an insightful comment on a blog, so which ingredient do you prefer?

Social Bookmarking, especially on the bigger sites like Digg and SU would be like adding tennis balls to the meal, or overcooking the fish perhaps.

Why? Because the only thing these sites are going to bring you is an increased bounce rate.

Social Bookmarking traffic is far from targeted, and although it is a numbers game in the end, is it really worth your time?

I tested out using StumbleUpon heavily for a month and received over 1200 visitors from there alone. That month my bounce rate went from 40 to around 65%.

(Note from Ana: interesting statistics, Alex – I’ve been thinking of learning more about StumbleUpon traffic; I guess what’s the rush? :)

Marketing (Eat In or) Take Away

Building relationships through blog commenting is without doubt the most powerful way of building both the backlinks and the credibility of your blog.

Like a good ingredient, a blog has a history and a unique story, and each one that you engage with and bring into your own circle increases the tastiness of your own blog and spices up the possibilities to no end.

Stop worrying about Social Bookmarking and Directory Submissions and all the other links you build simply because it seems like the right thing to do and concentrate on what will actually make your own blog delicious!

I’m not saying to only limit your backlinks to blog commenting; far from it.

I am simply suggesting that if you look at each link and each comment, and each relationship as an ingredient, you might start to see the blogosphere and where you best fit, in a whole new light.

Will this ultimately be better for your own growth? Without a doubt!
Will you finally find your own flavor?

Only Thyme will tell…

  • Have you found Blog Commenting to be the most effective way of getting your voice heard?
  • What other “Ingredients” do you use or recommend?

Marketing TakeOut from Ana

I was entirely blown away when Alex submitted this guest post.

Of course, mostly because Alex is such a smart cookie and I LOVE reading his posts, but there is another reason…

You see, Lisa from TheFriendlyBlogger.com and I (well, most Lisa really – she did all the work :) ) were working on an experiment/research on whether blog commenting REALLY does bring traffic. Stay tuned for the results – coming later this week!

Alex Whalley

Alex Whalley is the owner and founder of Build | Rank | Profit: The Niche Site Marketing Blog and the Principle Consultant at BuRP! Consulting, a Sydney based Search Engine Marketing Firm. Connect with Alex at the official Build Rank Profit Blog and learn EXACTLY how to Build, Rank, and Profit from Niche Sites today!

Image source: sweetwheat.com

traffic generation cafe comment below

{ 33 comments }

Andy August 19, 2012 at 9:14 am

Nice post Alex, I fully agree with you and instead of just relying on Google we can ‘produce’ our own Traffic – as I (we) can prepare my own Pizza and Pasta-sauce at home – it’s some work, but going for a take home pizza takes time also ;)

Ana Hoffman August 20, 2012 at 9:25 pm

Especially with all the latest Google changes…

Andy August 22, 2012 at 6:22 am

Nobody will touch my pizza – not even Google ;)

Ana did you ever try to ‘feed the Animal’ ?

How? – just put a Adsense Widget and Google analytics onto your Site(s) – I was told this helps against ‘bad Cold’.

Ana Hoffman August 22, 2012 at 8:20 am

Haven’t heard anything to support that, Andy; plus I am exercising my right to go against the flow. lol

Curt July 22, 2011 at 10:54 am

My current blog is just 1 month old. Through all the standard methods, including Twitter and LinkedIn, I’ve increased my traffic quickly. However, I realize I need a lot more, because if I’m not daily working the connections, stumbles and tweets, the traffic diminishes quickly.

I knew commenting was necessary, and obviously the sociable thing to do, but have thought it takes so much more time.

Thanks for opening my eyes witht his article. Your point was well put. I’ll be commenting now on all the blogs I come across that I’ve liked.

Ana July 22, 2011 at 11:20 am

Curt, it takes a bit of time to build up substantial traffic and consistency. Apart from being sociable, commenting on other blogs brings traffic to your site. Thanks for stopping by. :-)

William Agbo May 19, 2011 at 9:10 am

Alex,

I’ve learned so much today, I can’t believe I have been missing all that information.

I started a blog like 3 years ago and after one post didn’t know what else to do because I hardly understood the whole concept of blogging. So for me, I just want to let the lessons learned in this post to just sink in and settle in my spirit. Soon, I’ll be able to make better comments.

Thanks Alex, and Ana too for the whole website. You’re helping me.

William

Ana May 19, 2011 at 1:02 pm

You are so very welcome, William!

Ana

Matty May 19, 2011 at 4:31 am

Alex,

Since the inception of my blog, visiting and commenting on other blogs did more for the growth of my mine than any other methods. I can’t tell you how many times I received a visit from someone saying they noticed my comment on someone’s post and decided to visit my blog.

Sure, social media venues do add value and bring in a certain amount of traffic, but in my humble opinion, nothing matches the staying power of commenting.

As an added note, I agree with you that visiting and commenting on a variety of blogs is best. Some of the best relationships I’ve made started with a visit to a small blog with a minimal following.

Matty

Dean Carlton May 1, 2011 at 11:46 am

Interesting read Alex – I had been wondering whether I was ‘missing a trick’ not using SU / Digg.

Like Ana, I will also now relax about rushing to use them. I will focus my efforts on making better use of Twitter / FB and good old social-interaction.

This is a first for me – having LESS to do after reading a post at the TG Cafe!! ;)

Alex May 1, 2011 at 5:44 pm

“This is a first for me – having LESS to do after reading a post at the TG Cafe!! ”

hahah love it Dean.

That can only be a good thing right. ;)
Thanks for commenting mate, glad the post helped you to not do something LOL

Jamie Ferguson March 8, 2011 at 6:45 am

I didn’t realize how useless SU really was. I knew I’d get traffic and a lot of people would end up clicking and leaving, but now I’m starting to see that it’s not worth the time. Better to spend the time where it actually matters.

Thanks for this insightful post, Alex!

Alex May 1, 2011 at 5:45 pm

My pleasure Jamie,

Hope you can make strides where it matters most -thanks for your comments

Connie McKnight March 3, 2011 at 9:29 pm

Alex,
I really enjoyed your post. I’m so glad you said the blog comment was the best ingredient in your Bloghetti. My Google Analytics report, confirmed that I am getting a lot of traffic from my blog commenting. I didn’t know if this was the norm, and now I do. I feel that commenting gives you a real sense of community.

It certainly is a win win situation. Building relationships, getting traffic, and gaining knowledge all at the same time – what more can you ask for?

Thanks for writing such a tasty post.

Connie

Alex March 4, 2011 at 4:28 am

Hey Connie!

Thanks so much for sitting down to enjoy my pasta :)
I definitely agree with your summary of blog commenting, and really who can go wrong with a trifecta like that!

Again, I appreciate your energy in my (Ana’s) comment thread :)

Ryan March 1, 2011 at 4:45 am

I think commenting is a great way to initiate that first conversation with a blogger without just sending them a direct contact. It’s like being at a networking event and chatting with the speaker and follow up with their ideas, but just on a computer.

From there you can build the relationship and take have a lot higher chances of getting a guest post accepted or even a backlink because they like you and know you.

I had really good luck with this on one of my niche blogs where I commented a ton on authority sites and was able to guest post on the high ranking sites which gave me a ton of exposure, but it all started with commenting.

Like your ideas, and creative title!

Robert Dempsey February 28, 2011 at 10:02 pm

Without a doubt blog commenting does bring in traffic. I’ve had numerous people contact me via my contact form at the IEJ and tell me that they came from a blog I commented on.

Great way to connect both with the readers of the blog as well as the blog owner. Definitely be strategic about it. I look at the amount of traffic and conversions from all sources and divide up my commenting time accordingly. That way I can be sure to get reach but also focus on those places that are the most useful from a business standpoint.

Alex March 1, 2011 at 6:08 am

Robert mate, I have read your comments before and it is no surprise that most of your (converting) traffic comes from this source/

Its all about engagement after all, and a comments thread provides the first point of contact in most cases.
Thanks for sharing your experiences and insight mate

Sheila Atwood February 28, 2011 at 8:30 pm

Alex,
It makes sense to make commenting a complete package by becoming a guest blogger. You would really be adding to the blog community you are in.

Big fish and little fish is another package. For me the little fish and their readers are usually become my subscribers.

Alex March 1, 2011 at 6:09 am

Hi Sheila,

I think you put it best when you said that the little fish are the ones that will ultimately become your readers too.

There in lies the key ;)

Ronika February 28, 2011 at 6:05 pm

mmm…bloghetti…. Great analogy, Alex.
Your point about building relationships makes so much sense, but can be time consuming. And it can be difficult to find something meaningful to say.

Alex March 1, 2011 at 6:14 am

Haha thanks Ronika!
I agree and disagree with your last comment, because although it may be difficult to find something meaningful to say, who says you have to always be meaningful? You can be engaging, helpful, and just ‘there’ without necessarily having to provide thought provoking discussion with each comment.

I have to say on a side note though – if you take this attitude to your comments, you will make a name for yourself very quickly!
Thanks for your comment Ronika

Justin February 28, 2011 at 5:55 pm

I was wondering if Digg and StumbleUpon was helping or hurting my blog. I too noticed that my bounce rate is higher when submitting to those sites. I guess trial and error is part of the process. Thanks for confirming what I knew to be true. I’ll stick with commenting on blogs that I like, and participating in forum discussions.

Alex March 1, 2011 at 6:16 am

Ah Participating in forum discussions, now there is a medium through which the same principles can be applied!

Thanks for sharing Justin

StevenPapas February 28, 2011 at 4:40 pm

hey Alex, I love your writing. I liked the comparison betwen cooking and blogging. You are right to emphasize the caution we should exercise when writing comments in order to focus more towards adding to the discussion rather than only taking a link to our blog.

Alex March 1, 2011 at 6:26 am

Thanks Steven!

I appreciate the compliment, and I’m glad you thought the post was tasty :)

A Perfect example of someone who summarises the point you are making is Patricia the Lavender Blogger because she did not even realise that blog commenting was building backlinks!

Her small niche blog now gets hundreds of comments from those she been engaging in the blogosphere.

Go Patricia! LOL
Thanks for your comment Steven

John February 28, 2011 at 2:35 pm

I liked this subtitle Alex, “How to Cook the Perfect Bloghetti”. I agree with the piont you made on social bookmarking being like adding tennis balls to the meal. Of course you want more traffic, but you want that traffic to convert.

Sending traffic to your blog that only increases your bounce rate is pretty much a useless ingredient. Thanks for sharing Alex, and I look forward to checking out the results from your blog commenting experiment Ana.

Alex March 1, 2011 at 6:28 am

THanks John, I actually came up with that about 2 seconds before I penned it LOL, the irony is that all my other attempts at metaphors took ages to get right. SUch is life :)

Thanks for commenting John, and Yes – Ana I am looking forward to the results too

Jane February 28, 2011 at 8:45 am

Hi Alex,

This is one of the greatest posts I have read recently.

I completely agree with what you are saying about SU traffic. I have experienced a huge hike in my bounce rate as well from 42% to 76% when I used to submit my posts to SU myself. I then stopped submitting my posts to SU for a while and then it drastically came back to normal.

In most cases I experience that if I submit my posts to SU myself; I get fairly large numbers and hence a bad bounce rate. But if I leave it, there are indeed some people stumbling that post (lesser compared to me submitting it directly) but this doesn’t affect my bounce rate much. I don’t know the secret.

Jane.

Alex March 1, 2011 at 6:31 am

Now that is how you start a comment! LOL, thanks so much Jane, I appreciate the feedback.
I also thank you for taking the time to share your experiences with some of these (supposed) traffic sources.

BTw, if you find out the secret, I’ll give you a million dollars for it :)

Alex Whalley February 28, 2011 at 8:24 am

Thanks Dev.

I think having you as the first commentator is quite fitting because you are one of the first bloggers I connected with through commenting that then enabled me to connect with others.
In fact, I believe that through TechnShare was how Ana and I first met – so there you go.
The power of blog commenting and community comes full circle.
Thanks Dev- and it is YOU that is awesome my friend, your a great Blok(ub)e indeed :)

Roger Holmes February 28, 2011 at 7:23 am

Alex,
Interesting topic and some points to ponder because even though i’ve heard many times that blog commenting is a great source for backlinks and traffic I haven’t done it on any one blog consistently enough to really see a huge difference. It sounds as though it’s worth a try.
The concern about using the other social media sites to syndicate content and bounce rate is another point that caught my attention. I belong to a syndication tribe and that’s primarily the sole purpose behind the tribes to spread content over the social media universe and increase traffic.
I can see your point on how a lot of that traffic may not be targetted and thus increasing bounce rate…hmmm…so all traffic isn’t good traffic.

Thanks for sharing Alex

Roger

Alex Whalley February 28, 2011 at 8:28 am

Roger,

Blog Commenting works just like good content and guest posting, in that if you do it inconsistently and without focus then it all goes to waste.
Staying and becoming part of multiple communities helps bring those communities back to your blog and I think this is what makes the blogosphere so powerful. Its just about harnessing the viral power that community can bring, and of course the only way to get that is through commenting :)

Don’t get me wrong, your syndication is still a great idea – just keep in mind that if you are sharing content that is not necessarily of interest to your target audience, then you are mirking the waters of your own community before you have a chance to dive in.

Thanks for sharing your thoughts Roger. Glad you enjoyed the pasta, I mean the post ;)

Sorry, Comments are Closed. Stop by My Facebook Page With Your Comment.

Previous post:

Next post: