by Ana Hoffman 126 comments

Conversion Optimization: How to Make More Money with Less Traffic?

271 Flares 271 Flares ×

traffic conversion optimizationIt goes without saying that most of us want more web traffic.

The more traffic we generate, the more subscribers and customers we’ll get, right?

Right.

And WRONG.

There’s a glaring hole in “the more, the more” theory, and as you guessed it, this is what we’ll be talking about this week.

Conversion Optimization

Imagine all the work you have to put into increasing your blog traffic: writing quality content, guest posting, mingling on social media, working on your SEO rankings

Now answer this question: considering all the work, would you rather get 1,000 visitors and convert 100 of them into paying customers (10% conversion rate) or 10,000 visitors and convert 100 of them (1% conversion rate)?

Rhetorical question, I know.

So before you ask me “How do I get more traffic to my blog, Ana?“, let’s ask ourselves:

How Can We Do More Business with Less Traffic?

We all tend to fall in love with our site designs and often ignore the fact that they simply don’t work for our readers.

Since Traffic Generation Cafe started in July of 2010, it’s been redesigned THREE times.

The sad thing is that the first two times it was redesigned because I wanted it “to look pretty” and include some of the features I came across on other blogs and thought they were great.

Never occurred to me to actually do some testing to see whether any of those features actually helped or HURT my conversion optimization.

…Until I stumbled upon a Google Analytics feature that I never bothered to use before.

In-Page Analytics.

I was very unhappy to find out that so many features I thought were great were in fact simply cluttering my blog.

Take a look at this video I’ve made BEFORE I gave Traffic Generation Cafe a new makeover in December and see what worked and what didn’t.

We’ll talk about:

  • One or two navigation bars?
  • What actually gets clicked on your navigation bar?
  • What about your sidebar? What do your readers want to see there?
  • Should you use related posts plugins?
  • And more…

Conversion Optimization Problems Addressed

Fast forward one month.

My blog looks pretty much the way you see it right now.

How much traffic conversion improvement has Traffic Generation Cafe seen since the redesign?

And here’s another video I made AFTER I redesigned my blog:

So as you can see, working on tweaking your design to increase conversionĀ optimization never ends.

I’ve got a long way to go…

Conversion Optimization Marketing Takeaway

There are plenty of tools to help you optimize your blog design. Some of them are listed on my internet marketing tools page.

However, most of us don’t make an effort to work on conversionĀ optimization because it sounds complicated and time-consuming.

With a simple and FREE tool like Google In-Page Analytics, there’s no excuse.

It’ll take you about 5 minutes. Do it now.

Yes, it’s that important.

I do hope my redesign experiment will encourage you to take a look at your own site and try to figure out what works and what doesn’t BEFORE you spend gazillion hours driving traffic that will never stick.

traffic generation cafe

traffic generation cafe comment below

{ 126 comments }

Jens P. Berget February 26, 2012 at 1:40 am

Hi Ana,

I have been redesigning my blog a lot, and I have no idea how many times. Since I’m starting my own business, I have started to have a different focus on what I’m doing online. And I have switched to the Genesis Framework.

What you’re saying is very important, and I keep thinking that I should be asking my readers about their opinions. But I haven’t. I keep looking at the stats (I’m using Clicky) in order to improve the important parts of my blog. And I keep adjusting the strategy for my blog to fit my business strategy.

Thanks a lot for sharing this Ana. Hope you’re having an awesome weekend.

Ana Hoffman February 26, 2012 at 1:29 pm

I think you’ll find that your readers will be more than happy to help if you ask them, Jens.

Stats are great, but in the end, they are just numbers. Easy to find out what might not be working, but then you still need to find out why and what to do about it.

Ron December 7, 2012 at 8:35 am

I find a survey now and again on “how can I improve” helps. If you REALLY want to know what needs to be changed or improved on, ask the ones that spend time on your site, whether it be a blog or a website. They will be honest and you can get some great ideas in the end! I loved your videos and tips…you can never had too many ideas…but you can have too few or none! Thanks again for the tips, sometimes we all need a little help or a boost. Oh almost forgot, your blog looks great, simple and easy to navigate…busy can really confuse and run people off.

Danica Green February 21, 2012 at 7:15 pm

I learned something new today about conversion optimization. You are right that not at all time the theory “the more… the more” because there are cases when an increasing input on something decreases its total output.

Ana Hoffman February 22, 2012 at 10:40 am

Quality over quantity, Danica.

Sanjay Nair February 13, 2012 at 11:10 pm

Once again, a very insightful post. The last time was blog was redesigned was around 4 years back. Maybe its time I gave it a tweak. And yes, I need to take a detailed look at the In Page Analytics again.

Ana Hoffman February 14, 2012 at 7:26 am

Definitely sounds like it’s about time, Sanjay.

Boutros February 6, 2012 at 9:05 am

Very nice post Ana (as always). Website re-design/improvements should always in progress.
The Google ‘In-page’ analytics is great. I just checked on my blog and discovered that some menu items are never clicked (very very little). That something could be kept at the footer menu and removed from the Top menu.
Definitely ‘Most Commented Posts’ or ‘Most Viewed Posts’ grabs visitors attention.
There is a lot more work to be done for me.
Thanks for opening my eyes.
Boutros.

Ana Hoffman February 7, 2012 at 7:14 am

You are so very welcome, Boutros; glad I could add to your to-do list!

Lenia February 3, 2012 at 8:29 am

Hi Ana,
Well, i have to tell you that I opened Google Analytics while watching your videos. I have never used again the in page analytics. I find the analysis you make here very helpful and interesting. I have just learned one more thing and that is thanks to you. So I am grateful :)
I have a question if you don’t mind: do you have some conclusions about the use of 2 navigation bars on the header of the page? I saw you had two in the firsts video but you have just one now. Why? Did you conclude that this type of design confuses the visitors?
I am asking because I am currently working on redesigning my english blog in a WP platform and I thought that the two bars is a great idea. But as you explain very well what it matters is if this idea is great for my visitors and not only for me!

Thank you for the videos. Great information as always.Ii am stuck to your site :)

Ana Hoffman February 3, 2012 at 9:38 am

Two answers to your question, Lenia:

1. The bottom nav bar with all the category links wasn’t clicked on.
2. The more choices you give to your readers, the less they choose.

That’s why I found that I needed to take away some of those options.

Lenia February 3, 2012 at 11:09 am

Oh yeah, I double checked the first video…I see some stats on the list and link building but you mention it is very low…
Ok, I got it! Thank you for the tips.

Have a great WE!

Leon February 1, 2012 at 10:27 am

I have tried looking up the In-Page analysis for my website. But for some reason I get an error message which says:

“Your site doesn’t load ga.js from Google. If you host the Google tracking code on your own servers, it isn’t updated automatically and can miss important changes.”

What does this mean? Any suggestions? I am using thesis theme

Ana Hoffman February 1, 2012 at 12:50 pm

Take a look at the comment below from Ileane, Leon – she had the same problem.

Alan January 31, 2012 at 3:10 pm

Hey Ana,

this is great but I miss the old design!

I realise that may not be a popular thing to say but I really liked the ‘feel’ of your site – particularly the colour scheme which was your own unique scheme.

I love the cafe idea and the cafe-friendly colours you used to have. I get why you have changed the actual content & structure but surely you could have done this whilst keeping the same colours (or were you bored of them).

Don’t get me wrong, I do like the minimalist feel (my site is similar with a really bare design & white background).

It looks to me like lots of sites are going for the white background these days so your site is becoming like the rest – but it already looked great!!

It still looks good but in my view not as good as it was – sorry but it’s my view and I think in any case you’ll appreciate the feedback even if it’s not just great post, great job Ana etc etc.

It is a great tip about the in page analytics and about removing unused buttons (I didn’t need GA to tell me my social media buttons weren’t clicked I think a lot of people are social media button blind these days anyway) – but I just don’t think you needed to change your colours – for me that is part of your brand and you have a really great brand.

Even for example your social media icons – even if they weren’t clicked that’s not to say they never will be and even then, even if they’re not they looked really cool and contributed to a really professional look & feel within your superb ‘cafe’ theme,

hope this makes sense, just a bit of feedback, in any case, you’re awesome & so is your content I just have to say I preferred your old colour scheme (including the very clean borders around your posts, & carefully thought out & co-ordinated graphics).

Apart from the colours (which I’m assuming you don’t get any stats for) you are doing what any great business does & measuring – what gets measured gets improved!

Ana Hoffman January 31, 2012 at 7:04 pm

I completely understand, Alan, and I did like the old design quite a bit.

However, we need to stay with the times or even be ahead of times in this business…

Alan February 1, 2012 at 10:00 am

Wow. I was only trying to help Ana ;-)

Ana Hoffman February 1, 2012 at 10:31 am

I know, Alan – did I say something that made you think otherwise?

Truth is I don’t like change. I’d rather stick with what I know…

Too bad doesn’t work too well with online businesses. lol

Alan February 1, 2012 at 10:58 am

no worries Ana, I just found your reply a little short (perhaps businesslike) that’s all.

Made me feel like a bit of an idiot for writing (and caring) so much in the comment in the first place.

I was actually interested to hear your feedback on my feedback ;-) e.g. why couldn’t you just simplify but preserve the branding & colour scheme, or do the stats actually extend as far as telling you that changing the colours will convert better (I didn’t see that in your vids)?

Obviously if you were just tired of the old colours then that’s different. Here I go again – why am I re-writing this?

Alan February 1, 2012 at 3:08 pm

Please just ignore me, I didn’t mean to sound so grouchy!

Ana Hoffman February 1, 2012 at 8:37 pm

Well, I generally felt that the blog looked very “behind”, very old-school.

Plus, the way it was laid out, I couldn’t add some of the functions I wanted to, so I needed to redesign the layout, and once I started doing that I decided I might as well play with “cleaner” look as well.

Alan February 2, 2012 at 7:13 am

I do kind of get your point but I thought it looked good.

The new look is very up to the minute (in my opinion still not as good as the old one but I get your point) the only problem is it looks the same as everyone else now. Take the guy who commented below who has another ‘traffic cafe’ – virtually the same colour scheme. As are lots of others (including mine but I did mine ages ago, different niche and mine’s blank just because it’s very minimaliist, not for any conversion reasoons).

Anyways – thanks for answering I’m going to stop bothering you now ;-)

All in all the business fix side of it (giving more prominence to what works, getting rid of what doesn’t) makes total sense (obviously)

I still think you’re awesome :-)

Danielle Parsons January 30, 2012 at 9:24 pm

Great post Ana! Detailing how you improved your blog in regard to Google Analytics was very helpful to me. I have a bounce rate of 80 percent right now. I need to bring that down. I did notice there is a large increase in traffic coming from mobile devices. There is so much to learn and I am glad I am teachable.

Thanks for the help you gave me last year on getting my blog focused in on a particular niche. Now my site is advancing in Alexa rank and I am attracting the right visitor to my site!

Ana Hoffman January 31, 2012 at 8:08 am

So glad to hear that, Danielle!

Yes, mobile marketing is on my list to learn more about…

Ana Hoffman January 30, 2012 at 9:08 pm

Catch up, Barry!

Ana Hoffman January 30, 2012 at 9:01 pm

Thank you, Michael.

Sorry, Comments are Closed. Stop by My Facebook Page With Your Comment.

Previous post:

Next post: